Return To Blog Page

Nonprofit vs. For Profit LIHTC Sponsors: How Transaction Structuring Differs

By Rose H. Eaton, Chief Credit Officer, Managing Director - Funds Management

Read In 11 minutes

The Low Income Housing Tax Credit program was built on a simple premise: private capital, channeled through a project sponsor, will produce and preserve affordable housing more efficiently than a direct government subsidy. The program has never treated all sponsors alike. Whether the entity standing in the general partner seat is a 501(c)(3), a 501(c)(4) […]

Explore More

The Low Income Housing Tax Credit program was built on a simple premise: private capital, channeled through a project sponsor, will produce and preserve affordable housing more efficiently than a direct government subsidy. The program has never treated all sponsors alike. Whether the entity standing in the general partner seat is a 501(c)(3), a 501(c)(4) nonprofit or a for profit developer changes the mechanics of the transaction from allocation through Year 15 exit.

For taxpayers and institutions evaluating a transferable credit or a tax equity position, understanding those structural differences is not academic. Sponsor type affects underwriting, guarantee exposure, exit timing, and how cleanly a transaction can close. The following walks through where nonprofit and for profit LIHTC transaction structures diverge and why it matters to anyone sitting across the table from either type of sponsor.

The Nonprofit Set-Aside Starts Every Comparison

Section 42(h)(5) of the Internal Revenue Code requires that state housing credit agencies reserve a portion of their annual credit ceiling,  not more than 90 percent may go to projects outside this category,  for developments involving a qualified nonprofit organization, commonly called the 10 percent nonprofit set-aside. Many state Qualified Allocation Plans (QAP) reserve a larger share than the federal floor requires.

To qualify, the nonprofit must be a 501(c)(3) or 501(c)(4) organization with fostering low-income housing among its exempt purposes, must not be affiliated with or controlled by a for profit entity, and must both own an interest in the project and materially participate in its development and operation throughout the full 15-year compliance period. “Material participation” borrows its definition from Section 469(h) passive-activity rules,  involvement that is regular, continuous, and substantial, not a passive check-the-box role. A nonprofit that holds only a minimal partnership interest, delegates all operational decisions to a for profit co-sponsor, or receives credits without a genuine ownership stake risks the entire allocation being disallowed on IRS review.

For profit sponsors are not eligible for set-aside credits at all. Their transactions compete in the general (non-set-aside) pool, where allocation is driven primarily by a Qualified Allocation Plan’s scoring criteria rather than nonprofit-status requirements.

Ownership and Control: Co-General Partner Structures

Because nonprofit sponsors often lack the balance sheet or construction risk inclination that tax equity investors expect, many nonprofit sponsored transactions pair the nonprofit with a for profit co-developer in a joint venture general partner structure. The nonprofit typically holds the managing general partner or a controlling co-GP interest to preserve the set-aside eligibility and its material participation standing, while the for profit partner often serves  as an administrative general partner or guarantor, takes on construction completion guarantees, operating deficit guarantees, and tax credit recapture indemnities.

This division of labor is typically documented in a Memorandum of Agreement negotiated prior to the partnership operating agreement being finalized. A well-drafted MOA allocates the developer fee split, defines capital contribution and staff responsibilities, assigns recourse liability, which tends to fall more heavily on the for profit partner since guarantees from a 501(c)(3) raise separate tax-exemption concerns, and lays out how the Year 15 exit will work, including any GP purchase option or nonprofit right of first refusal.

Straight for profit sponsored transactions skip the MOA. A single for profit general partner typically holds both the developer role and the guarantor role directly, simplifying the control structure but concentrating recourse liability and fee economics in one entity rather than splitting them across a joint venture.

Guarantees Sit Differently on a Nonprofit’s Balance Sheet

Tax equity investors generally require the project sponsor to guarantee construction completion, operating deficits, and against credit recapture. A for profit sponsor provides these directly. A nonprofit sponsor providing the same guarantees to a for profit investor raises a tax-exemption question: does guaranteeing another party’s return constitute private inurement or benefit inconsistent with the nonprofit’s charitable purpose?

The IRS has generally treated affordable housing development as a charitable activity. Guidance in this area (including consideration under Revenue Ruling 2004-51) has given practitioners some comfort that reasonable, arm’s-length guarantees tied to a genuine ownership stake do not by themselves jeopardize exempt status. But the analysis is fact-specific, which is why nonprofit-sponsored transactions frequently route guarantee obligations to the for profit co-developer or to a nonprofit affiliate structured to isolate risk, rather than having the 501(c)(3) itself stand behind investor return.

A separate wrinkle applies when a nonprofit holds a meaningful interest in the ownership entity.  The tax-exempt use property rules under Section 168(h) can limit the depreciable basis available to the for profit investor since a portion of the property may be treated as used by a tax-exempt entity. For profit investors evaluating a nonprofit entity involved transaction typically ask their tax advisors to model this exposure before pricing the investment  since it can reduce the depreciation benefits the credit pricing otherwise assumes.

Developer Fees and Economic Splits

Developer fee treatment is one of the more heavily negotiated points in any joint venture MOA, and it plays out differently by sponsor type. Fee mechanics can vary by state and by transaction type,   some Qualified Allocation Plans set higher fee caps for bond financed or 4 percent transactions.  Some require  a nonprofit or CHDO co-sponsor receive a minimum share of the developer fee to preserve set-aside eligibility, but these variations are driven more by transaction structure and state policy than by a general rule favoring nonprofit sponsors. In practice, industry commentary has noted that nonprofit developers often lack the negotiating leverage of large, repeat for profit sponsor and can end up with less favorable terms on price per credit, fee timing, and reserve requirements even where the state’s fee cap would otherwise permit better economics.

Deferred developer fee is a related structuring tool used by both sponsor types.  A portion of the fee is left unpaid at closing, included in eligible basis to generate additional credit proceeds, and repaid out of cash flow over the compliance period. The mechanics are identical regardless of sponsor type, but a nonprofit relying on deferred fee to fund overhead has less flexibility to absorb a slow lease up or delayed repayment than a for profit developer with other fee income streams.

The Year 15 Exit: Where the Sponsor Type Matters Most

The clearest structural divergence shows up at the end of the 15-year compliance period. Section 42(i)(7) gives certain parties, project tenants, a resident management corporation, a qualified nonprofit organization, or a government agency,  a statutory right of first refusal to acquire the project at the end of the compliance period.  In nonprofit-sponsored transactions, it is typically the nonprofit sponsor itself, or an affiliated entity, that holds this right. The ROFR price is generally the lesser of the property’s restricted fair market value or  the statutory minimum.  The outstanding debt plus exit taxes, is  in practice  usually the operative, below market number. For profit sponsors have no equivalent statutory right of their own.  The exit options run through negotiated GP purchase options in the partnership agreement, a sale to a third party, or the Qualified Contract process which is when an owner can compel the state agency to find a buyer at a formula based price or release the property from its affordability restrictions.

This difference has downstream effects on how investors and secondary buyers price and underwrite a position. Nonprofit sponsored transactions with a clean ROFR pathway have historically seen a smoother, more predictable transfer of ownership at Year 15, because the source of the investor’s return and the endpoint of nonprofit ownership are well understood by both sides entering the transaction. For profit sponsored transactions more often exit through a negotiated GP option or open-market sale, which can extend timelines and introduce more valuation negotiation.

That said, ROFR execution has become more contested in recent years. Disputes have arisen where replacement or secondary market investors challenge a nonprofit’s exercise of its ROFR, question whether a purchase offer was truly bona fide, or resist agreeing to a fair market value determination tied to a sponsor held option. Any party evaluating a nonprofit sponsored transaction approaching Year 15 should confirm the ROFR mechanics and pricing formula are documented clearly in the partnership agreement, not left to be worked out later.

What This Means for LIHTC Investors and Secondary Buyers

Unlike the investment and production tax credits used in Fallbrook’s renewable energy platform, LIHTC is not on the list of credits eligible for the Section 6418 direct transfer election created by the Inflation Reduction Act. LIHTC is still monetized the traditional way,  through tax equity syndication, where an investor takes a limited partnership (or LLC membership) interest in the ownership entity to claim the credit directly, rather than buying the credit itself in a standalone cash transaction. That means a LIHTC investor is, by definition, a partner in the transaction which is exactly why sponsor type carries through the entire life of the investment rather than ending at a single transfer date. Material participation compliance under the nonprofit set aside, guarantee structure, and recapture risk all bear directly on the durability of the credit the investor is claiming. An investor has no privity with obligations the sponsor owes to its co-general partner, but a Section 42(h)(5) noncompliance finding.  For example, if a nonprofit’s participation is later found to be insufficiently substantial that determination can  put the underlying credit at risk for everyone holding an interest in the partnership. Before entering the ownership entity an investor should:

  • Confirm whether the credit was allocated from the nonprofit set aside, and if so, review the nonprofit’s ownership percentage and role in day-to-day operations.
  • Ask how guarantee and recapture indemnity obligations are allocated between co-general partners, and to whom recourse would run if a default occurred.
  • For transactions approaching Year 15 confirm whether a nonprofit ROFR, a GP purchase option, or a negotiated sale governs the exit The investor should also  determine how pricing is set under each.
  • Review whether deferred developer fee is outstanding, and confirm the repayment timeline sits within the compliance period.

The Bottom Line

Nonprofit and for profit LIHTC sponsors are not interchangeable counterparties. The nonprofit set aside, material participation standard, guarantee and tax exempt use constraints, and the Section 42(i)(7) right of first refusal all shape a nonprofit-sponsored transaction differently from a straight for profit structure, particularly around who bears recourse risk and how the project ultimately changes hands. For taxpayers, investors, and secondary buyers of LIHTC partnership interests, sponsor type is a threshold question worth confirming early, not a detail to sort out at closing.

Fallbrook Financial Services works as a facilitator and intermediary connecting taxpayers to qualified tax credit opportunities across renewable energy, affordable housing, film and entertainment production, and historic rehabilitation.

Sources

Internal Revenue Code Section 42, Low-Income Housing Credit — Cornell Law School Legal Information Institute:  https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/42

IRS Low-Income Housing Credit Audit Technique Guide:  https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-utl/IRC42%20Low%20Income%20Housing%20Credit%20ATG%20Part%201.pdf

Novogradac, “Partnering with a Nonprofit for a LIHTC Development”:  https://www.novoco.com/periodicals/articles/partnering-nonprofit-lihtc-development

Novogradac, “QAP Set-Asides” series:  https://www.novoco.com/notes-from-novogradac/qap-set-asides-post-2-10

A.J. Johnson Consulting Services, “Nonprofit Set-Aside Issues for LIHTC Properties”:  https://www.ajjcs.net/paper/main/2014/01/02/nonprofit-set-aside-issues-lihtc-properties/

A.J. Johnson Consulting Services, “Allocations Under the Nonprofit Set-Aside — IRS Requirements”:  https://www.ajjcs.net/paper/main/2015/09/28/allocations-under-the-nonprofit-set-aside-irs-requirements/

Mahoney CPAs and Advisors, “Not-for-Profits and the Section 168(h) Election: Considerations in LIHTC Deal Structuring”:  https://mahoneycpa.com/not-for-profits-and-the-section-168h-election-considerations-in-lihtc-deal-structuring/

“Pushing the Limits: Nonprofit Guarantees in LIHTC Joint Ventures”:  https://www.att-law.com/post/pushing-the-limits-nonprofit-guarantees-in-lihtc-joint-ventures/

Preservation of Affordable Housing, “Non-profit Purchase Options Need Strengthening in LIHTC Program”:  https://www.poah.org/news/non-profit-purchase-options-need-strengthening-lihtc-program

Shelterforce, “Nonprofit Housing Developers Deserve Better LIHTC Terms”:  https://shelterforce.org/2024/06/25/nonprofit-housing-developers-deserve-better-lihtc-terms/

Enterprise Community Partners, “Year 15: Transition Strategies for Expiring LIHTC Properties” national training materials:  https://www.enterprisecommunity.org/sites/default/files/2025-03/Year15_National_Webinar_Presentation.pdf

Tax Credit Advisor, “Developer Fees: Dispelling Myths About a Vital Resource”:  https://www.taxcreditadvisor.com/articles/lihtc-developer-fees-vital-resource/

HUD Loans, “A Close-Up on the Low-Income Housing Tax Credit Program”:  https://www.hud.loans/hud-loans-blog/lihtc-program-hud-multifamily-loans/

Disclaimer: This article is provided for general informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute legal, tax, accounting, or investment advice. Tax credit structuring rules, including nonprofit set-aside, guarantee, and exit provisions, are fact-specific and subject to change; readers should consult qualified legal and tax counsel regarding their particular circumstances. Fallbrook Financial Services acts solely as a facilitator and intermediary in connecting parties to tax credit opportunities and does not act as a broker-dealer, investment adviser, or provider of legal or tax advice. No statement in this article should be construed as an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any security or tax credit interest.

Other Blogs

Fallbrook